skip to main content skip to footer

Cakes & Pies

Harry Potter book cake with magic wand and eyeglasses
mermaid themed birthday cake with candles
hedgehog shaped cake
Tiffany & Co. box shaped cake

"You Dream It, We'll Make It!"

If you are planning a party or a special event, please contact us to make the cake of your dreams.

Cakes

HAVE YOUR CAKE...

Get it Gluten Free ($5 extra), or Vegan ($10 extra)!!

Blue Ridge Hummingbird
A moist cinnamon-flavored cake full of ripe banana and sweet pineapple. Covered in cream cheese frosting and sprinkled with chopped nuts... $36.95

Butter Gap Vanilla
Lots of fresh butter and real organic vanilla make this cake anything but ordinary... $36.95

Pink Beds Strawberry
Layers of fresh strawberry cake frosted with fresh strawberry buttercream. Only available when strawberries are in season... $36.95

Cascade Falls Carrot
Moist carrot-studded spice cake, frosted with our signature cream cheese frosting and sprinkled with chopped nuts... $36.95

Rich Mountain Fudge
Tastes like Grandma's chocolate cake. A chocolatey, rich fudge cake frosted with our creamy chocolate buttercream... $36.95

Devil's Courthouse Red Velvet
Moist cocoa-infused red cake, slathered in cream cheese frosting... $36.95

Schenck German Chocolate
Fluffy chocolate cake frosted with our own homemade cooked coconut pecan frosting... $42.95

Rocky Mountain Chocolate Kahlua
An intensely chocolate cake brushed with Kahlua and frosted with a cooked fudge frosting... $44.95

...AND LOVE IT TOO!

If you can dream it, we can design it!

We specialize in custom cakes for birthdays, showers, anniversaries and other special occasions.

CUSTOM CAKES
*Get it Gluten Free ($5 extra) or Vegan ($10 extra)!!*

1/4 Sheet Cake
15 to 24 servings, 9 x 13 inches... $39.95

1/2 Sheet Cake
35 to 45 servings, 13 x 18 inches... $65.95

Full Sheet Cake
85 to 99 servings, 18 x 26 inches... $125.95

10-inch 2 Layer Round
20 to 25 servings... $47.95

12-inch 2 Layer Round
35 to 40 servings... $70.95

vanila cake with sprinkles and "Tinley" written in icing
treasure map cake
cake decorated like a unicorn
Wizard of Oz themed cake

Holiday Pies!

pecan pie with caramel drizzle and sea salt flakes
mini pies with turkey cartoon decoration

Apple | $16.95

Apple Praline | $17.95

Blackberry Crumb | $16.95

Blueberry Crumb | $16.95

Bourbon Pecan | $17.95

Cherry Bourbon | $16.95

Chocolate Silk | $16.95

Chocolate Mixed Nut | $17.95

Coconut Cream | $15.95

Derby Pie | $15.95

Key Lime | $15.95

Lemon Chess | $15.95

Lemon Meringue | $16.95

Maple Apple Cranberry | $16.95

Mince | $17.95

Pumpkin | $15.95

Pumpkin Praline | $17.95

Sweet Potato | $15.95

GF Chocolate Brownie | $16.95

Pumpkin Cheesecake tart | $24.95 
with Honey Swiss Meringue

Chocolate Caramel Tart | $24.95 
aka “Eddie Pie” 

cherry pie with star crust
baked pecan pie in pie tin